I in addition to expose the results having fun with almost every other complimentary strategies as an effective robustness consider

As past literature has noticed that the newest ATT can differ with respect to the complimentary strategy, we expose our results for around three different complimentary actions: (1) coordinating that have an excellent kernel Epanechnikov and you will a data transfer regarding 0.1; (2) complimentary toward around three nearest natives within a distance regarding 0.01; and (3) so you can restriction even further the newest assessment group, we fits treatment and you will control individuals within metropolitan/rural, age, and you will university attendance condition (on the a lot of time-manage estimates, i merely limit to help you metropolitan/rural and decades).

An element of the email address details are displayed playing with a propensity score detailed with linear, squares and you may communications terminology. Brand new model using the MxFLS research spends 108 variables together with model by using the EMOVI investigation utilizes 57 parameters. 18 The latest robustness point comes with results for additional requirement of one’s inclination get. Also, i expose robustness monitors on diary chances proportion given that complimentary rating instead of the inclination get. Typically, the results are stable across criteria and you may coordinating strategies.

We were 86 parameters within the 2002 towards the estimate of inclination score having MxFLS: age, several years of education, college attendance, work position, native language, expertise in contraceptives, early in the day sexual pastime, rural status, and you can dad absent on the household

We imagine different examination to validate harmony in the inclination score. Basic, we provide visual proof according to overall performance from the Dehejia and Wahba (1999, 2002) before and after matching in order to validate this new balancing in addition to commom service assumptions. We likewise incorporate the brand new stratification try pre and post matching proposed by Dehejia and you will Wahba (1999, 2002). 19 Next, we are the standard bias scale advised by Rosenbaum and you will Rubin (1985) pre and post complimentary. 20 We report precisely the average standardized prejudice. Predicated on Caliendo and you may Kopeinig (2008), an average standardized prejudice lower than 5% try “adequate.” Third, given that recommended because of the Sianesi (2004), i statement the new p-property value the shared advantages test of one’s tendency rating model both before and after matching. 21 Next, i declaration new part of details you to are not able to refuse the newest null theory away from equivalent setting before and after matching. Eventually, i statement the amount of observations on the cures and you can handle for each and every coordinating strategy. With all of these types of examination, the point is to bring proof in favor of new balancing and you may popular service assumptions.

Contour 3 shows field plots of land and you will histograms before and after complimentary. Presenting the outcome, i use step three nearest natives contained in this a radius out of 0.01. The fresh new profile, with the results for both the MxFLS and you can EMOVI, shows that before complimentary, the treatment and you may manage teams are not dramatically other. Prior to matching regarding the MxFLS (Panel A great), the fresh indicate property value the brand new inclination get to your manage category is roughly 0.10 and also for the addressed classification it is around 0.twenty-five. With the EMOVI (Committee B), the fresh new indicate philosophy was even better. Boards E and you may F inform you the box plots of land just after complimentary. The container plots of land don’t show variations in the range of the fresh propensity rating between therapy and you may control. Boards C and you may D reveal just how many observations on cures and you can control by s teach there is an adequate amount of findings regarding handle category to complement the latest treated group. This new after coordinating histograms demonstrate that for every single decile i have a great deal more observations on the handle than in the newest handled classification, with the exception of the major decile on MxFLS.

I have 72 correspondence conditions between personal parameters (many years, education, performs, local, experience with contraceptives, and you will prior sexual pastime) and you will family details and you may squares of age and you will several years of education

Source: Authors’ data. Notes: Immediately following coordinating, rates make use of the form of 3 nearest residents in this a radius from 0.01. On the container plots of land, 0 describes handle observations and you may step 1 to treatment findings. Throughout the histograms, the newest x-axis provides several rows: the first line means handle and you will medication, while the second line in order to deciles of estimated tendency get. This new details incorporated towards lead bogota hot women of your domestic was: numerous years of degree, decades, women, and performs condition. We additionally include household size, and you will family relations 0-5, 6-18, more than 65, mediocre instances has worked on home, mean ages, and you may money for every single capita of one’s family, number of room regarding domestic, and dummy parameters getting domestic possessions, such as for example: no auto, zero kitchen stove, zero public liquids solution no sewage solution. We are 57 details in the quote of the inclination get for EMOVI: years and age squared, created in rural areas, and you will facts about both parents when individual was fourteen years old, such: studies, works reputation, formal industry business, native language, exactly what father or mother the individual try managing. I have information about the family: number of siblings, domestic dimensions, number of bedroom and trucks, and you can dummies out-of house property including: zero kitchen stove, zero washing machine, zero fridge, no tv, no societal liquids provider, no sewage service, no electricity. Ultimately, we through the affairs away from personal variables that have house features as the really as squares and connections away from several years of education off both mothers, and you will work updates away from both dad and mom.